Print Page | Close Window

Loss of Power After Take Off

Printed From: Just Flight Forum
Category: Just Flight Products
Forum Name: PA-28R Arrow/Turbo Arrow III/IV and Warrior II
Forum Description: Discussion area for the PA-28 aircraft (PA-28 Arrow III, Turbo Arrow III/IV and Warrior II)
URL: http://forum.justflight.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=31504
Printed Date: 27 Apr 2024 at 4:48pm


Topic: Loss of Power After Take Off
Posted By: tanker82
Subject: Loss of Power After Take Off
Date Posted: 28 May 2017 at 6:23am
Hi: I don't know if this is something I did, but after taking off in the Turbo Arrow for the first time, I could not maintain power or climb. I could barely keep the plane airborne.  It was as if I was experiencing carburetor icing, but should there be icing in a turbo charged aircraft? Anyway, the plane is beautiful, and once this issue is sorted out, I'm sure it will be perfect.  Mike Gutierrez, North Hollywood, California



Replies:
Posted By: nippa
Date Posted: 28 May 2017 at 10:31am
This has been puzzling several of us given that the real TA IV has something of a reputation for poor handling.

The real pilot's handbook is available online from the Swiss Flying School ... flugschulebasel.ch and has proved useful.

Before departure do a maximum power run-up while setting fuel mixture and propeller pitch to achieve a maximum manifold pressure and rpm. Now look at your trim and set it to nose up by quite a bit.
By doing this when you slowly open the throttle you achieve the best you can without going over the red lines and hopefully with the trim back so far you will unstick cleanly.

In this way I can cruise close to book speeds although rarely achieving 75% power...something feels wrong.



Posted By: taildraggin68
Date Posted: 28 May 2017 at 1:55pm
Same issue here on the IV model only.  Support ticket sent.  As a temporary work around, I did copy/rename the III fde to the IV model folder saving the original.  I'm sure they can fix this in short order.


Posted By: Delta558
Date Posted: 28 May 2017 at 8:35pm
Using the airfile from the 3 and renaming it is the way to go for now - there should be only one very slight difference between the 3 and the 4 airfiles and that is to do with the elevator, nothing at all to do with the engine. Clearly something has got muddled somewhere, I haven't had a chance to look into it yet but hope to find the problem early tomorrow.

Cheers,
Paul.


Posted By: THibben
Date Posted: 29 May 2017 at 2:25pm
My IV is working perfectly as far as I can tell.  It gets right up to speed and handles very well.  I have made several landings and all were very good.

Tom 


-------------
Tom


Posted By: Martyn
Date Posted: 30 May 2017 at 2:14pm
Please download and install the latest version of the product -  http://www.justflight.com/support/pa28-turbo-arrow/32f5bd1" rel="nofollow - https://www.justflight.com/support/pa28-turbo-arrow/32f5bd1

Apologies for the inconvenience.

Thanks
Martyn

-------------
Martyn
Just Flight Ltd


Posted By: nippa
Date Posted: 30 May 2017 at 5:55pm
Originally posted by THibben THibben wrote:

My IV is working perfectly as far as I can tell.  It gets right up to speed and handles very well.  I have made several landings and all were very good.

Tom 

I can't get into a cruise climb as the model ( just the IV ! )  is still underpowered ; I've sent a ticket.


Posted By: anthonye
Date Posted: 30 May 2017 at 7:10pm
Same here
Same as before, no change.

Anthony


Posted By: Delta558
Date Posted: 30 May 2017 at 7:13pm
Have you downloaded the new version from Martyn's post? There should be NO difference between the III and the IV air files except for one table to do with the elevator. That was the problem - somehow in the original download the file had become corrupted, I took the elevator table and put it in the III airfile (which nobody has had a problem with), renamed it for the IV and it should now be okay.

Incidentally, the only differences in the aircraft.cfg file are the aircraft selection and the tail details within the airplane geometry section.

Engines, drag etc should now be identical between the III and the IV.

Cheers,
Paul.


Posted By: anthonye
Date Posted: 30 May 2017 at 7:51pm
Well yes I have, thats why I posted here.
Hell of a job to take off, the last time I checked the III that was fine on the previous version.

Anthony


Posted By: anthonye
Date Posted: 31 May 2017 at 11:19am
Either one will only go to around 2000ft, and trimmed the max speed is around 90 to 95.
The low tail will climb better but it just seems to be the 2000ft mark it plays up.
The rpm does not drop, but the sound of the engine seems to drop off gradually.

I think this is a problem with the FSX-SE versions that are causing the problems, would be interesting to see what the others are using if they could be bothered to add to this and just say "ok here". On my non turbo versions you will see in another thread I had even a problem with the panel state loading incorrect, until found a procedure to workaround this.

Can't see any way forward for the problems with the Arrow's it does get very frustrating just more info would help.

Anthony






Posted By: nippa
Date Posted: 31 May 2017 at 1:59pm
Hold fire

Support have just sent me some new files and the IV flies nicely now but only at the second attempt after manually adding them and overwritng the existing files.

Could it be that the new  air and cfg files are not overwriting the old when doing a lazy install over the old version?


Posted By: anthonye
Date Posted: 31 May 2017 at 2:21pm
Originally posted by nippa nippa wrote:

Hold fire

Support have just sent me some new files and the IV flies nicely now but only at the second attempt after manually adding them and overwritng the existing files.

Could it be that the new  air and cfg files are not overwriting the old when doing a lazy install over the old version?


I did a clean install as always.

Would have nice to have been sent the files as well to test.........

Anthony


Posted By: wingmanab
Date Posted: 31 May 2017 at 2:21pm
+1 with new installer.
At recommended decent power settings (20" and 2300) with mixture rich the Piper assumes a 2000' decent. Holding the pitch to 500' minute causes indicated speed to fall near to stall.
I don't have to non turbo version, so cannot patch files.
I'm using FSUIPC to control all axis, but have rechecked calibration, and they seem fine.
Something's up.


Posted By: anthonye
Date Posted: 31 May 2017 at 2:23pm
Originally posted by wingmanab wingmanab wrote:

+1 with new installer.
At recommended decent power settings (20" and 2300) with mixture rich the Piper assumes a 2000' decent. Holding the pitch to 500' minute causes indicated speed to fall near to stall.
I don't have to non turbo version, so cannot patch files.
I'm using FSUIPC to control all axis, but have rechecked calibration, and they seem fine.
Something's up.


I thought it was fsuipc as well as you, checked it and it's fine, not that causing the fault.

Anthony


Posted By: wingmanab
Date Posted: 31 May 2017 at 2:46pm
Checking against performance tables for climb from sea level, we should see close to 1000'/min at max power settings (41" and 2575rpm, at normal take off weight (2400lb which is full tanks and one passenger).

Just checked this, as see less than 500'/minute, so definitely a marked difference to standard operating performance.




Posted By: Martyn
Date Posted: 31 May 2017 at 2:47pm
A new installer is now available which contains the updated Arrow IV FDE.

Thanks
Martyn


-------------
Martyn
Just Flight Ltd


Posted By: Delta558
Date Posted: 31 May 2017 at 3:36pm
Please uninstall the old one and delete any leftover files before using the new installer. FSX has a nasty habit of not fully overwriting files and just dropping the new install over the top of the old can result in problems. If for any reason these files don't fix your problems we can then eliminate at least one part of the install process!

If you then are not seeing book figures, then there is definitely something amiss. We have several Turbo Arrow pilots on the testing team and they are happy that it is realistic to their aircraft and showing the correct speeds / climb and descent rates for given engine settings. I have taken the files in the new installer up in both FSX and P3D and see the same results in both sims.

Hope you get flying with this installer,
Paul.


Posted By: anthonye
Date Posted: 31 May 2017 at 4:32pm
Seemed ok at first, plenty of power. Got to 2500ft put the autopilot on height hold. After a few minutes at 2500ft power seemed to go down  slightly and speed dropped to about 60-70 then stalled.
Always seems to come in at around 2000ft.
No weather conditions, just the default.

Anthony


Posted By: Martyn
Date Posted: 31 May 2017 at 4:51pm
It's a long shot but what happens if you enable 'Carb heat/eng anti-ice' and 'Propeller de-ice' using the keyboard assignments ('H' etc)?

-------------
Martyn
Just Flight Ltd


Posted By: anthonye
Date Posted: 31 May 2017 at 5:19pm
Originally posted by Martyn Martyn wrote:

It's a long shot but what happens if you enable 'Carb heat/eng anti-ice' and 'Propeller de-ice' using the keyboard assignments ('H' etc)?


That's a thought, will try it later and let you know


Posted By: anthonye
Date Posted: 31 May 2017 at 7:41pm
Originally posted by Martyn Martyn wrote:

It's a long shot but what happens if you enable 'Carb heat/eng anti-ice' and 'Propeller de-ice' using the keyboard assignments ('H' etc)?

It was worth a try, but no difference.

Anthony


Posted By: THibben
Date Posted: 31 May 2017 at 9:11pm
Originally posted by Martyn Martyn wrote:

It's a long shot but what happens if you enable 'Carb heat/eng anti-ice' and 'Propeller de-ice' using the keyboard assignments ('H' etc)?

Martyn,

I flew a flight, as you suggested, with Carb heat/eng anti-ice and Propeller de-ice on.  There were no sound anomaly's.  The weird thing though was when I turned them both off the sound still didn't occur.  I tried it several times both from a standing start and from touch and goes. It was all the same with no noise.

The problem with the propeller de-ice is it just toggles on and off with the L key and there is no indication, that I could find, as to whether it was on or off.  I don't know whether any of this helps or not.

Tom


-------------
Tom


Posted By: anthonye
Date Posted: 01 Jun 2017 at 10:37am
Originally posted by anthonye anthonye wrote:

Seemed ok at first, plenty of power. Got to 2500ft put the autopilot on height hold. After a few minutes at 2500ft power seemed to go down  slightly and speed dropped to about 60-70 then stalled.
Always seems to come in at around 2000ft.
No weather conditions, just the default.

Anthony

Tried the Turbo III this morning that is exactly the same as the IV, where as  before this latest update it was fine.

I tried all checks now, will leave it to you.....

Anthony


Posted By: anthonye
Date Posted: 01 Jun 2017 at 10:52am
Originally posted by anthonye anthonye wrote:

Originally posted by anthonye anthonye wrote:

Seemed ok at first, plenty of power. Got to 2500ft put the autopilot on height hold. After a few minutes at 2500ft power seemed to go down  slightly and speed dropped to about 60-70 then stalled.
Always seems to come in at around 2000ft.
No weather conditions, just the default.

Anthony

Tried the Turbo III this morning that is exactly the same as the IV, where as  before this latest update it was fine.

I tried all checks now, will leave it to you.....

Anthony

Forgot to mention. If the Turbo is run first, the non-turbo cfg is all reset to zero's when it is loaded again, not good.

Anthony


Posted By: b1bmsgt
Date Posted: 01 Jun 2017 at 4:17pm
I tried the 102 version of the Arrow IV last night and experienced no problems. Cruised at 4000msl for about 30 minutes with no loss of power.

Russ


-------------
Master Sergeant, USAF, Retired
Former T-33A Crew Chief
Former B-1B Crew Chief/Maintenance Expediter
Former Learjet Corp. Quality Inspector


Posted By: anthonye
Date Posted: 01 Jun 2017 at 5:09pm
Looking back through the thread, looks like you do not have the problem.

Anthony


Posted By: b1bmsgt
Date Posted: 01 Jun 2017 at 6:08pm
Originally posted by anthonye anthonye wrote:

Looking back through the thread, looks like you do not have the problem.

Anthony


I didn't post it here, but I did enter a support ticket. The IV was acting pretty much how you have described it, but so far the update did it for me. Hope you have some good luck soon!

Russ




-------------
Master Sergeant, USAF, Retired
Former T-33A Crew Chief
Former B-1B Crew Chief/Maintenance Expediter
Former Learjet Corp. Quality Inspector


Posted By: BTSeven7
Date Posted: 02 Jun 2017 at 1:30am
I have the exact same problem as described above.  I have never been over 2500 feet in this aircraft and I have been trying for two days.  III or IV it all does the same thing.  No reason and no warnings.  I have done everything listed in this thread.  I did an uninstall and install of the newest version and still get the exact same thing.  I originally started with IV and then switched to the III when I read people didn't seem to have problems with that.  Didn't fix anything.

On top of everything else, my Garmin GTN 750 is basically unresponsive in this aircraft.  It turns on but the buttons are inoperable at times and very slow often if they do work.

I am using P3D v3.4, newest update of that and not V4.  I use SPAD.next for my saitek stuff and have a hotas warthog throttle.  Windows 10 and every other aircraft I use have no issues.  

Needless to say this has been one giant 48-hour headache.    


Posted By: anthonye
Date Posted: 03 Jun 2017 at 11:09pm
Just noticed, when this problem happens the fuel flow drops to 10 and the rpm drops to 180.
Mixture has not been altered and throttle is on full. 
Pump is on

Anthony


Posted By: Martyn
Date Posted: 05 Jun 2017 at 11:11am
Are you making sure not to overboost the engine? Here is some info from the FDE developer:

Quote
The first point is, with this aircraft you NEVER firewall the throttle. If you use full throttle, you will overboost the engine (Hg of roughly 46 at sea level - that is correct, confirmed by multiple real-world Turbo Arrow pilots). You should see the little square (greenish yellow at the top right of the panel) light up - that is the overboost warning light. You will also hear a kind of bubbling sound, which is the onset of detonation - the result of which is a loss of power, lower fuel flow and eventually complete failure of the engine.

Please try the following:

Full RPM and Mixture.
Throttle - advance slowly to just below the red line on the Manifold Pressure gauge (so roughly 40 - 41 Hg, you'll be able to take off as low as 38, but the red line is critical)
Carefully creep it briefly over the red line, check that the overboost light comes on (you may also hear the noise change with the detonation) then bring it straight back below.
Take off and fly around, try some climbs but keep the Hg at all times below the red line. You can use your mixture and RPM as normal.

You will find that, as pressure decreases with altitude, you will need to gradually increase the amount of throttle used to keep a given Hg, so that around the critical altitude for the turbo (12,000ft) you will probably have full throttle or somewhere near.


-------------
Martyn
Just Flight Ltd


Posted By: anthonye
Date Posted: 05 Jun 2017 at 12:18pm
[QUOTE=Martyn]
Are you making sure not to overboost the engine? Here is some info from the FDE developer:


Yes that was it when he sent me the above to try, works perfect now.
Sorry about the confusion totally my fault all the time. I was pushing throttle to full and keeping it there.

First time I've had a turbo prop  Embarrassed

Thanks

Anthony


Posted By: robwin
Date Posted: 29 Jul 2017 at 12:21pm
 Just downloaded and installed both the arrows for P3Dv4 and the turbo arrow appears to have the engine dying  problem again. Engine started to run out of power when above 6500 feet in spite of proper management ( I am a real world pilot ). The engine then caught fire . I wonder has the earlier fix not been applied to this aircraft ?


Posted By: Delta558
Date Posted: 29 Jul 2017 at 2:45pm
I don't have P3Dv4, so I cant test the fde in there but from what I can gather it shouldn't act any differently to v3.4 as the fde is still handled through the .air and .cfg files. There was no 'earlier fix' as such, just an incorrect file in the IV which was not a problem in the III. You don't specify in your post but you say you installed 'both the Arrows', is that normally-aspirated and Turbo, if so do you have the problem with both versions of the Turbo?

Cheers,
Paul.




Posted By: robwin
Date Posted: 30 Jul 2017 at 1:26pm
Hello Paul.. Thanks for your interest. I should have been more specific in my post. 

I have the original arrow 3 plus the turbo arrows version 3 and 4. it is the Turbo arrows I have the problem with. Each of these have different problems

In the turbo arrow 4 version, as I climb above about 3000 feet, the engine starts to slowly fade out. Just as it did in a previous release for the software for P3DV3. Just flight issued the `fix` I mentioned which cured the problem. Its as if it has fuel starvation. during one flight, I intended to level off at 7000 feet but the engine had other ideas so I reduced my altitude to 3000ft and levelled off. The engine then continued to fade and the fuel flow metre was reducing as the amount of fuel being supplied was becoming less and less.  The throttle RPM was showing 2500 even as the engine note was slowly reducing. If left to continue the engine will either die out or simulate and engine fire.

In the case of the turbo arrow 3 version. The engine starts to fade during the climb but I noticed that if I speed the sim up to x 4 speed the power comes back. In this aircraft I managed to climb to 9000 feet but then in the descent there was an unseen hand constantly pulling the throttle back. I tried increasing the throttle friction but it does n`t make any difference so I spent the flight constantly fighting the ghost in the right hand seat. The throttle wants to drop back to idle if you do not give it any input. All this happens in P3DV4 using a full set of Saitek controls and boxes and with FSUIPC 5 and spad next.

The normally aspirated arrow works perfectly as does the new PA28 161 warrior 2 that has just been released.

Hope the above makes sense

Regards.. Rob


Posted By: anthonye
Date Posted: 30 Jul 2017 at 1:54pm
I had the same problem until Paul corrected me. What I was doing was keeping the throttle fully open and showing in the red on the gauge. I think they called it firewalling which it does not like, damages the engine.

Anthony



Posted By: Delta558
Date Posted: 30 Jul 2017 at 3:05pm
Hi Rob,

Well, your description of the problem with the Turbo IV sounds like how MSFS depicts the onset of detonation (set within the sim itself). As I mentioned, I don't have P3Dv4 so I can't test to see if that is the case and I would be surprised if there was any difference in that area from how it was handled in previous versions. It is, of course, a possibility - might be worth you using a very long runway and much lower power settings, see if you can get airborne and maintain power and then gradually push the power up to see if you can find where the problem starts?

With the Turbo III, I've just done a similar flight (climb to height then descend) in v3.4 and don't see any throttle creep. The Hg and RPM also remain perfectly constant with either a gentle descent or steep dive near VMo.

It all says to me that v4 may have altered how it deals with turbos. That would definitely surprise me, but the fde should be identical as there is only one installer so it has to be either how the aircraft is being flown or how the sim handles it. From your description, you know what you are doing so we're left with the latter! Try the suggestion in my first paragraph if you can and if that doesn't give a clue it will probably be worth starting an official support ticket.

Cheers,
Paul.


Posted By: robwin
Date Posted: 30 Jul 2017 at 4:08pm
Hello Paul.. Thanks yet again for a prompt reply (even on a Sunday) !

I will try your suggestion and will also try the same aircraft in P3DV3.4  which I still have installed. I have installed all of the Arrows and Warriors  into both sims so I will compare them shortly. The Arrows were working fine in P3DV3.4 but I haven't tried them in P3DV3.4 since the dual installer came out for P3D. version 4. 

 I used to own a PA28 161 warrior 2 and apart from the lack of pitch up when the flaps are lowered that others have mentioned this aircraft is a credit to you guys.


Thanks again.. Rob


Posted By: robwin
Date Posted: 30 Jul 2017 at 7:03pm
After lots of testing on both sims. I found that both the turbo 3 and 4 arrows worked perfectly in P3DV3.4  I tried them again in P3DV4 and hey presto they worked perfectly. Even the ghost in the right hand seat pulling the throttle back disappeared.  The only thing I can think of is that I might have over boosted the engine during the initial phase of climb although I don't think I did.I made sure I kept the MP below the red line. This might have been the cause of the engine catching fire in a descent on the  tail Arrow 4 model.

The main thing is all is good now.

Thank you Paul and Anthonye for your suggestions.

Regards.. Rob


Posted By: Delta558
Date Posted: 30 Jul 2017 at 7:16pm
Phew! LOL


Posted By: tamsini
Date Posted: 31 Oct 2017 at 9:17pm
Hello all, I just bought this beautiful aircraft from FSPS for P3D v4.1 and now I'm getting loss of power above 3000 feet. Since it was just released, I assume it is the latest version (DUH!) and I have looked at several videos, read the manual and followed the checklists - all to no avail. It just stalls above 3000 feet. 

Has there been anything more to this thread than possible patch application? Very confused... and sad.

Regards,
Mario Di Lauro


Posted By: Martyn
Date Posted: 01 Nov 2017 at 10:02am
Hi Mario,

Have you read the info posted by Paul (Delta558) on the previous pages of this thread? If this is occurring with the Turbo Arrow variant then you may be overboosting on takeoff.

Thanks
Martyn


-------------
Martyn
Just Flight Ltd


Posted By: tamsini
Date Posted: 01 Nov 2017 at 11:16am
Martyn - thanks for that. \That did the trick. What threw me off is the manual says to apply full power during climb. But now I see how it works. Thanks again.



Print Page | Close Window